How Endowments and Foundations Can Address the Liquidity Challenge

Learn how endowments and foundations can manage liquidity risk, forecast cash flows and capital calls, and strengthen investment governance.

As alternative investments become a larger and more permanent part of endowment and foundation (E&F) portfolios, liquidity management is evolving from a tactical monitoring exercise to a core governance, forecasting and portfolio construction discipline. We’ve identified some of the liquidity challenges presented by alternatives and provide ways E&Fs can better align liquidity with their missions, spending needs and portfolio strategies.

The Liquidity Challenge Is Front and Center

According to a recent Morgan Stanley survey of investment decision-makers at endowments and foundations, alternative investments have surpassed public U.S. equities as the largest allocations in E&Fs’ investment portfolios.1 Private equity, private credit, real assets, hedge funds and other strategies are helping organizations pursue higher long-term returns, diversify beyond public markets and access opportunities that are not available through traditional asset classes.

Bar chart showing Asset Allocation as Percent of AUM

But the same characteristics that make alternatives attractive can create liquidity challenges that may affect organizations’ ability to fund spending goals, grantmaking commitments and day-to-day operations. In fact, nearly half of the survey respondents (47%) named liquidity as the single greatest challenge of using alternatives, up from 21% in 2023.1 Meanwhile, liquidity risk was named as the top portfolio risk at E&Fs, tied with spending shortfalls.

Bar chart showing top portfolio risk considerations

Adding to the complexity is the fact that alternatives — a category that includes a broad array of asset classes, strategies and vehicles — span the full liquidity spectrum, from a daily liquid gold ETF to a private venture capital partnership. The time required to convert an investment to cash depends on vehicle structure, redemption terms, manager discretion and market conditions, so organizations need understand and evaluate the characteristics of each investment.

 

A Sound Liquidity Framework Starts with Mission and Spending Needs

As alternatives become a larger share of E&F portfolios, liquidity planning should reflect the organization’s mission and spending needs, not just its investment portfolio. Management teams and investment committees should start by developing a full cash flow picture through a discovery process that includes:

 

  • Spending policy
  • Grantmaking schedule
  • Operating needs
  • Fundraising reliability
  • Donor flows
  • Seasonality

 

Cash flow forecasting, typically done for the short- to medium-term, along with longer-term strategic pacing models can help bring discipline to the framework. Effective models can track progress toward private-market allocation targets by projecting capital calls and expected distributions. These models should be informed by both top-down and bottom-up inputs, including capital-markets assumptions, relevant third-party data about industry trends, and data gathered from ongoing conversations with individual managers. The goal is to inform decisions about rebalancing, reserves and the timing of new commitments before liquidity becomes a constraint, and to help ensure illiquid allocations are sized appropriately so the organization is not forced to sell liquid assets at inopportune times to meet obligations.

 

The assumptions that go into these models should be refreshed as markets and organizational needs change. Spending policies should also be reviewed regularly because a policy that works well during strong markets may be harder to sustain when portfolio values decline or liquidity becomes constrained.

 

Through initial discovery and a sound evaluation framework, investment decision-makers can better assess whether the portfolio is positioned to support both long-term objectives and near-term obligations.

Governance Guardrails Can Reduce Pressure in Volatile Markets

Liquidity management should be a prominent and clearly articulated part of the investment policy statement (IPS) and embedded in board-level oversight. While about two-thirds of surveyed E&Fs monitor liquidity at least monthly, almost 40% do not explicitly define liquidity risk or establish decision rules in their IPS. That governance gap can become problematic during periods of market volatility, when decisions must be made quickly.

Percentage showing liquidity risks

E&Fs should document their expectations for and definitions of liquidity in the IPS, particularly for each asset class. Policy parameters may include minimum liquid asset levels, liquidity buckets, lockup limits, capital call reserves and reporting cadences. The IPS should also define liquid, semi-liquid and illiquid investments, so boards and investment teams have a common language for evaluating portfolio flexibility.

 

These guardrails should reflect the organization’s specific mission and spending obligations, not simply mimic peer practices or benchmarks. A tailored governance framework can help organizations stay disciplined when liquidity is under pressure.

How Consultants Can Help Turn Liquidity Planning Into Action

Consultants can help E&Fs turn liquidity management into a disciplined, mission-aligned process in several ways.

 

Education

 

An experienced consultant can help boards and investment committees better understand the liquidity nuances of alternatives, including lockups, redemption terms, unfunded commitments, private investment J-curve dynamics and the tradeoffs involved in seeking an illiquidity premium.

 

Suitability

 

A consultant can lead objective discussions about how much alternatives exposure is appropriate for the organization. For some, the expected illiquidity premium may not justify the added complexity and liquidity risk, while for others, the benefits of illiquid strategies are worth the tradeoffs.

 

Reporting

 

Frequent flash reports can provide near-term visibility into cash and liquidity, while deeper quarterly reviews can assess portfolio-level risks, pacing, commitments and reserve needs. With the help of a consultant, this type of reporting can support practical decisions about rebalancing, new commitments, reserves and spending adjustments.

 

Forecasting

 

Consultants often leverage data and input from investment managers to complement their cash flow forecasts that incorporate capital-market assumptions and organization-specific needs.

 

Manager access

 

An experienced consultant can identify, evaluate and provide their E&F clients with access to top managers. Investing with top-tier alternatives managers matters because return dispersion is often greater in alternatives than in traditional asset classes.

 

Ongoing discovery and governance

 

Consultants can help organizations revisit operating requirements and spending policies as conditions and needs change; they can also assist in translating liquidity analysis into practical governance tools on an ongoing basis.

Liquidity as an Ongoing Governance Discipline

For E&F boards and investment committees, liquidity should be treated as an ongoing governance discipline, not a one-time portfolio exercise. Working with a consultant can bring objectivity, discipline and manager insight to the process, helping organizations pursue the benefits of alternatives while preserving the flexibility needed to fund spending goals, operations and long-term mission commitments.