Morgan Stanley’s 2027 outlooks point to a resilient global economy, even as inflation poses challenges. Continued investment in AI infrastructure is expected to support growth and corporate earnings, creating a favorable backdrop for risk assets. Still, investors may face a bumpy ride, making quality and diversification key themes for the year ahead.
Seth Carpenter: Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Seth Carpenter, Morgan Stanley's Global Chief Economist and Head of Macro Strategy.
Serena Tang: And I'm Serena Tang, Morgan Stanley's Global Cross-Asset Strategist.
Seth Carpenter: And today, the second part of our conversation about Morgan Stanley's outlook for 2027, I'm gonna talk to Serena about how we are thinking about market swings, what's going to shape the investment outlook here in the United States, across the world, and across asset classes.
It's Tuesday, November 17th at 10:00 AM in New York.
Serena, markets have had a lot to digest this year, from the US invasion of Iran, and as a result, a surge in oil prices that have caused inflation concerns. We've had the US midterm elections, and recently we've seen swings in the equity market, especially in technology, and that shows just how much everyone's expectations about what AI is going to do can move markets.
So as you look ahead to 2027, can you give us sort of an idea, what is your broader investment outlook?
Serena Tang: It's great to talk to you again, Seth. A theme for 2027 is embracing risk. The AI CapEx cycle is intact. and Seth, you touched on the robust growth picture, in our conversation yesterday already.
And while, like, there clearly are still geopolitical risks, many of this year's big catalysts that have weighed down on the market are now behind us, including the new Fed chair and the midterm elections.
Even now, risk assets have actually cheapened. Global equities trade at around fifteen times forward earnings, the lowest since two thousand and twenty-three. So in this outlook, we've moved to a maximum overweight in global equities in our portfolio recommendations with overweights in the US, Japan, and Europe, and we fund that out of cash and commodities.
Seth Carpenter: That makes a lot of sense, Serena. I mean, embracing risk sometimes seems a little tricky, but we do have, in economics, a pretty fundamentally constructive outlook on where growth is going to go, even with a bunch of wobbles back and forth.
You talked about leaning into equities, but let's turn to the bond market. There's been a lot of discussion this year about debt issuance from the AI build-out. Do you see a lot of opportunity still in the corporate bond market, or is that opportunity set now just turning to risk?
Serena Tang: I mean, after a year of very heavy supply, foundations for high-quality credit have actually improved. So we've closed out, underweight in US investment-grade corporate credit. However, we do still expect record US IG issuance of around two and a half trillion next year, which is why we turned neutral on investment-grade corporate credit rather than getting a lot more constructive like we did for equities
Seth Carpenter: So would you say that your views and your team's views are in line with consensus, out of consensus? And how high would you say your degree of conviction is about this outlook?
Serena Tang: I would highlight a few views where we are out of consensus or where we have high conviction. Look, I touched on this before. With global equities, we're maximum overweight. Japan, for example, we're very constructive on, as it offers the best return relative to risk across our equity forecast, supported of course by reflation, which your team has touched on many times, and a private CapEx cycle and shareholder-friendly corporate governance.
Second is the duration in bonds and gilts, and of course, like, this is also very much tied to the economics views on how many hikes we're gonna get in those regions. In our view, the markets have priced in too many hikes, in the UK especially, which is why we're constructive on UK gilts.
One last view I wanna highlight, and that is our out of consensus view for stronger dollar, Driven by our view for more robust growth in the US versus rest of the world.
Seth Carpenter: All right. That makes a lot of sense. I will say though, the theme Embrace Risk, that's important, but the word risk brings something else to mind for me, which is how could we be wrong? If you're gonna be wrong about this, where is it going to show up, right?
So if you look at your forecast, if you look at the outlook, what are the ways in which your investment prescriptions for investors could go wrong?
Serena Tang: Look, there are several ways we can be wrong about our very constructive stance on global equities and our more neutral stance on fixed income. They're basically what you mentioned yesterday around the various risk scenarios, from the economics team. The first, I think something that everybody's talking about, is the possibility of an abrupt end to the AI investment cycle.
Given tech concentration in indices and in positioning, equities of course would suffer, and credit would sell off in sympathy. The second is oil. Our base case has Brent trending towards seventy-five by the end of two thousand and twenty-seven. But a retest of the highs of this year, would of course reprice the Fed and the ECB, push yields above our forecast, and dent equities.
The third, of course, is inflation re-accelerating. That has nothing to do with oil. It would force more tightening than two further hikes from the Fed, our economists expect, and of course, move yields and rekindle debate over the cost of AI debt financing, which in turn dampens risk sentiment.
Seth Carpenter: All right, so the last subject I have to get you on is one that comes up in every single client meeting I have, which is what are the implications of the outcomes of the US midterm elections for your investment thesis? How critical is that for what you're recommending to clients for 2027?
Serena Tang: That has been a question we've been getting in every single meeting since the midterm election outcomes, especially on whether it challenges a much more constructive view on AI CapEx cycle being intact.
On build-out, we see a delay, not a pause. As our US public policy strategist and US corporate credit team have been arguing, Data center restrictions are a state-level story. Projects already under construction or permitted should be insulated, and we don't really expect a federal pause. So we've kept our 2027 US hyperscale or CapEx forecast at around $1.7 trillion in cash and leases, but simply shifted about five gigawatts of US projects from 2028 to 2029.
I think all this really points to an extended cycle, a good thing for equities.
Seth Carpenter: Serena, why don't we end it there? I have to say, it's always a pleasure getting to talk to you about how the economic outlook ties together with the investment outlook.
Serena Tang: Always a pleasure to talk to you, Seth.
Seth Carpenter: And to the listener, thank you for listening. If you enjoy Thoughts on the Market, please leave us a review wherever you listen and share the podcast with a friend or a colleague today. I know my mom listens.
Serena Tang: Actually, my mom does listen to this.
Serena Tang: Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Serena Tang, Morgan Stanley's Global Cross-Asset Strategist.
Seth Carpenter: And I'm Seth Carpenter, Morgan Stanley's Global Chief Economist and Head of Macro Research.
Serena Tang: Today and tomorrow, a two-part conversation on Morgan Stanley's year ahead outlook.
Today, we'll focus on the global economy after a year of energy shocks and renewed inflation pressure. Tomorrow, we'll be back with our views on investing across asset classes.
It's Monday, November 16th at 10:00 AM in New York.
So Seth, let's start with the big picture.
It's been a challenging year to map the global economy with the war in Iran, shifting trade policies, and more recently, US midterms, adding uncertainty even as AI investment supports growth. As you look ahead to 2027, what's a story that ties it all together, and where do you see the global economy heading?
Seth Carpenter: Sure. I mean, the interesting thing I think so far might be a bit of a surprise, to date, about how, dare I use the word that's been overused a little bit, how resilient global growth has been.
We've had a whole series of shocks. We've had the energy price shock. Last year, we had tariffs. We've seen now developed market central banks starting to raise rates, and yet overall growth is holding up. And so we've titled the outlook this time, Powered by AI, Tested by Oil, because there really is this underlying momentum that's going on that is about this whole AI phenomenon.
In the United States, the build-out, the CapEx infrastructure spending is clearly strong, and it's one of the key drivers of US growth. But it's a global theme because Asia, where the world supply chain in many ways is located, is getting a lot of growth by exporting components for this build-out. Europe is actually getting into the game there a little bit as well, and Japan has been part of it.
So this AI phenomenon, that's global, and that's a big part of what's sustaining growth. But oil prices have gone up dramatically since the US invasion of Iran, and so we have to ask ourselves, what is going on with inflation? We've seen, headline inflation globally go up. We know that the spread of refined products over crude is higher than usual, so that risks more inflationary pressure coming through later.
And so we've seen central banks hiking in response. So the question becomes then, can this underlying momentum overcome the adverse shocks that we're seeing? I'd say our view is, yeah, probably. 2027 might see a little bit of a lull, a little bit of a slower pace initially, but that's not because we think we're actually going to have a real slowdown in the global economy.
It's just the growth rate this year is pretty strong. It's gonna be hard to top that regardless of what's going on.
To take that narrative and just to summarize it, to put it in numbers, to make it easier to digest, this year, global real GDP, we think, is tracking at about three and a half percent, so 3.5%. Next year, that little bit of a lull that I talked about would bring it down to something like 3.3% before rebounding in twenty twenty-eight to about 3.4%.
Now, that doesn't sound like a huge swing, and ultimately, we don't think it is. We are constructive about the growth rate of the global economy. But these little swings, especially when you think about it at a global level, can start to matter, and investors are gonna look at the data as they come in.
Serena Tang:
So you've given us the picture at the aggregate level. I actually want to dig a little bit more into the regional views. Where do you see faster growth? Where do you see slower growth? And what does inflation look like globally?
Seth Carpenter: Yeah, those are key, questions, and I think all of the conversations that I have with investors really touch on that. So I would say, first off, the US is clearly a key driver here, right?
So the AI CapEx build-out is absolutely taking place in the biggest part in the United States. And there we're looking for growth, call it two and a half to two and three quarters percent this year and about the same next year. So by US standards, that's really strong, growth numbers. Inflation, we think, is gonna stay high here as well.
We've seen the energy price shock feeding through. We know that the statistical agencies often have a little bit of what we call residual seasonality in the inflation data in the beginning of the year. And so we suspect that we're still gonna see a few more months of high inflation data. But if our forecast is right, and this is a critical if, if our forecast is right, Q1 will be the peak of inflation, and then we'll see it start to trend down in the United States because we do think growth remains solid.
But so far, we don't really see overheating going on in the labor market. Now, across the Atlantic in Europe, we're also pretty constructive. So a growth rate of around one and a quarter percent or so, of real GDP growth for Europe.
It's much less fast than what we're seeing in the United States, but nevertheless, it's holding up. That's being driven by a little bit of extra exports to the US, but fiscal policy clearly in Germany still supporting things, and the periphery is holding up in terms of overall demand.
Inflation there feels a lot like inflation in the United States. However, the economy is much more susceptible to, inflation energy price shocks. And so that's why the ECB started hiking before the Fed did.
We think there's probably another hike there. We also expect inflation there to drift down over time, but it's gonna take a while, and the divergence between the headline inflation numbers and the core inflation numbers might actually be a bit bigger in Europe than elsewhere.
Now, Asia. Asia's a really interesting story, and we're used to thinking of China as the other big economy in the world. And that's true, but their growth right now is on the tepid side by Chinese standards. We expect that to continue because they're still working through this debt deflation cycle.
And so four and a half percent or so, growth next year is about what we're looking for. We do think that deflation's going to ebb, but not anytime soon. That outcome is in contrast to the rest of Asia, especially take Korea, Taiwan, the real exporting houses for this whole AI CapEx build-out phenomenon.
Again, growth rates are gonna tell you a different story because the spending has been rising so rapidly now. We expect exports to stay very strong there. But in growth rate terms, it might actually come off, not because things are fundamentally weakening, but because you just can't keep that same pace of exporting going.
Serena Tang: So you touched on this earlier already, but as we know, inflation this year has driven a lot of debate around the Fed path.
So what are you expecting for 2027?
Seth Carpenter: Yeah, I mean, I think bring it back to the Fed and inflation, that really is the key story. On the growth side of things, things are holding up. We think the labor market is fine but not overheating, and so the whole story driving what the Fed's going to do comes down to inflation, like you said. So look, we expect, like the market does, another hike by the Fed in December.
We're looking for another hike in March. The market's gonna debate are they gonna slip another one in in January. But we don't think so. We think we've got two more hikes from here, December and March, and then that's it. What will it take for that forecast to come true? It's gonna mean that our inflation forecast also has to come true, which is to say firm inflation now, but no clear signs for an acceleration from here.
Because if things really pick up from here, then that January hike that the market's talking about might come true. It also means, though, that our forecast that Q1 is the peak of inflation in the United States and then it's a downward trend after that, that has to come true as well. Otherwise, it's entirely conceivable that the Fed would put in another hike after March, maybe in June, because they really want that assurance that inflation is coming down.
Serena Tang: And how you framed it just now, I think, is the important thing, right? What markets are pricing in versus our expectations. In which case, what is your most out-of-consensus view on the global economy in 2027?
Seth Carpenter: So I would say, you know, overall I don't know that we're wildly out of consensus anywhere. I would say we're probably above consensus in terms of our forecast for US growth. We are building in continued strong aggregate demand, but we're also penciling in an increase in the growth rate of productivity, partly because we do think, AI adoption is going on.
So that's one place where we're out of consensus. And then I guess I would come back to our discussion about inflation and what it means for central banks. The market is going to be debating a lot how much central banks are going to hike, how soon inflation's going to abate. Our view is, you know, Q1 is about the peak, and after that things come down, and so central banks won't have to hike more than that.
I would say if we're wrong, there are probably more paths to more rates from central banks and higher inflation than to lower. So I would say that's one place where I think our view maybe has a bit of tension with at least the way the market's trying to price things.
Serena Tang: Now, you've talked a lot about the base case. What are some of the alternate scenarios you see for the global economy?
Seth Carpenter: Yeah, I personally think it's critical to come into any round, forecasting round with a base case. But that only gets you so far. You really have to ask yourself, "How could we be wrong?" And so what we tried to do was to sketch out four alternate scenarios that have some of the key risks that we think are there in the economy and that we're talking to clients about in markets.
So in terms of a faster growth scenario, there really are two key, scenarios that we tried to analyze. One demand, demand for CapEx, demand for consumer spending, especially in the United States, where demand overall is just stronger than we think, and that outcome leads to faster growth, but it also leads to much higher inflation.
And so in response to that, the Fed and other developed market central banks are gonna have to raise interest rates more and maybe to the same peaks that we saw in the last hiking cycle coming off of the COVID inflation. On the other hand, we're trying to figure out how is AI adoption happening?
How much can productivity pick up? And so we also thought about a faster growth scenario where it's mostly driven by faster aggregate supply, that is, the productivity picks up faster. And the big difference there is that you're able to get faster growth without the same kind of inflationary pressures.
Now, central banks everywhere are going to see that, and the first thing they see is faster growth, Anytime you have faster growth from productivity, anytime the underlying potential growth rate of the economy is faster, it tends to mean that the neutral equilibrium interest rate is actually higher, and so you could get slightly higher interest rates than under the baseline, even though inflation is well-behaved.
Now, We, we are pretty constructive, and we do think there's probably more upside risk than downside risk, but we can't bury our heads in the sand. And so one version of the world is that the oil price shock that we've seen comes back, and we have oil prices going up a lot.
Central banks will see that, and they'll have to react to that. And the way that AI CapEx build-out is driving all of the growth right now, question that we get from clients a lot is: What would happen if that fell short of your expectations?
And I think that's worth thinking about too, because you have a combination of the direct spending, the direct effect of this build-out that's leading to more GDP, more growth, more exports from East Asia. But you also have an indirect effect, which is this whole phenomenon has driven up asset prices, which has given households more wealth, which has allowed strong spending to continue.
And so if those factors both went away, you would have a negative effect on the direct channel of spending and an additional drag on the economy from the indirect wealth channel. And for us, that means a slowdown. Probably not a recession. like I said, we're pretty constructive about what's going on with AI anyway, but one would have to at least consider what would happen if these spending plans fall short of our current forecast.
Serena Tang: And of course, all of those risk scenarios just means The range of outcome for risk assets is unusually wide.
Seth Carpenter: Yeah, I think that's right.
There is a huge amount of uncertainty here. We are in uncharted territory in so many ways. The AI phenomenon all by itself is just a brand-new situation for everybody in markets. But energy prices and everything that's going on in that space, there's still a lot of uncertainty.
We've had a series of these supply shocks and how that may or may not get embedded into inflation psychology in the way that price setters and price takers react to that inflation, that's uncertain as well. So I, I really think it is fair to say there's a very broad range of possible outcome here, and investors around the world are going to have to pay lots of attention.
Serena Tang: And of course, we're gonna be talking about that in our next podcast. Seth, thanks for taking the time to talk.
Seth Carpenter: Serena, it is always great to sit down with you and talk through these issues. I'm gonna turn the tables on you tomorrow and ask you about markets.
Serena Tang: Of course. And thanks to our listeners for joining. Please be sure to tune in to the second half of this conversation tomorrow to hear how we're thinking about investment strategy in the year ahead.
If you enjoy Thoughts on the Market, please leave us a review wherever you listen and share the podcast with a friend or colleague today.
Vishy Tirupattur: Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I am Vishy Tirupattur, Morgan Stanley's Chief Fixed Income Strategist.
Today, a special conversation with one of the most seasoned professionals in credit at Morgan Stanley, Dan Toscano, on AI, credit, and the interplay between them.
It's Thursday, November 5th at 11am in New York.
Dan, last time we chatted here, you were very constructive on the potential for AI to be transformative in the economy and markets, and even more constructive on the role that credit markets will play in enabling that transformation.
So, any way we cut it, we are talking about trillions of dollars of CapEx involved in the context of AI buildout. How are you thinking about the AI thesis, AI CapEx thesis and the role that the credit markets are playing?
Dan Toscano: And every time I talk to you, the numbers go up. These numbers continue to expand. The opportunity set continues to expand for our clients. And I would say that nothing surprised me of what we've seen over the course of 2026.
This is not simple, and this is not easy. And there are, as our CEO likes to say, known unknowns. And they factor heavily in the sentiment of investors. And when you're deploying trillions of dollars of capital in a way that has never been deployed in our lifetimes, there are bound to be air pockets.
And so yeah, it's gone as I thought it might. And it just keeps getting bigger and bigger. And it's interesting to me that a lot of the discussion out in the marketplace these days has moved a little bit away from ‘what is this and how does it work’ to ‘what's the value proposition?’ And I think ultimately, that's the biggest question.
And credit investors are asking that question in the form of trying to understand what can go wrong. It's the essence of a credit investor. And equity investors, although that's not my area of expertise, are asking, "What's the upside? And how should I value it today when a lot of these companies are going public for the first time?"
Vishy Tirupattur: The markets are really questioning the return on the invested capital. How soon the returns will get realized? And monetization is the key word here.
But at the back of this, we see that the level of rates have increased pretty meaningfully. Spreads have widened. So, overall borrowing costs for issuers here are clearly higher.
So, on the back of this, do you see this as really a structural supply concern? The markets having to absorb a lot of supply. Or do you see this as being something larger than that? Is it a sign of a larger challenge within the credit markets?
Dan Toscano: Yeah. I mean, there's a lot to unpack there.
But look, I would say this. On the topic of, you know, what is the return? What is the value proposition? I've heard, really, two schools of thought from the marketplace. One is we think the return value proposition is high. And you've done some work on the early stages of this to value it.
So, I hear people saying there's almost unlimited upside here, and I hear people saying, "I don't know what the value proposition quite is."I haven't really heard anyone say I think this is a stinker. And I think that's, you know, somewhat emblematic of the world we live in.
But in terms of the cost of capital, I don't think we're seeing any of that in… Obviously underlying rates behave independently, and they're a function of a lot of factors, many of which are positive. And I keep reminding people that the backdrop that we conveniently pass by when we talk about this is an economy that is strong. Issuer earnings have been into the double digits quarter after quarter.
And that's not something I would take for granted. And that can change. And it's done that despite energy instability, all the other things that are impacting the consumer. And yet, you know, we're producing earnings growth and cash flow that are significant.
But back to your question about spreads, in particular. I mean, look at where spreads are today. They are, in my opinion, tight. I think we were at the all-time tights over the course of this year. And so, it's hard for me to sit here and say all this AI-related financing is driving up the cost of capital.
We don't see it in spreads. And, you know, I think the debate around the impact of the trillions of dollars that need to be raised in all markets has yet to play out in the marketplace. People are talking about it, right? It's understanding that volume is coming in scale really hasn't happened, when you think about it. But the market I spend the most time in, non-investment grade credit markets, it's been quiet now for months.
Vishy Tirupattur: In all my years of talking to you and learning from you, the one thing that's always stood out for me is: details matter. And especially when we talk about leveraged credit. So, in the context of AI financing in the leveraged credit market or the broader credit market, what type of details matter?
Dan Toscano: Yeah. Well, it is true. Look, I think that it's evolving. We've talked, I think the last time we were here, we talked about the documents. You know, the documents matter. Investors are always complaining that the terms are too loose. But in the case of what is essentially project finance, I would say details matter in all caps. And put as many exclamation points after that as Elaine Benes would allow, if you remember the Seinfeld reference.
Vishy Tirupattur: Indeed, I do.
Dan Toscano: And so, you know, understanding the details of the lease. And to me, the fundamental question that underpins details matter is: what can go wrong? And if something goes wrong, what happens? And who's taking what risk?
And you'll find that in the documents if you read them closely -- in project financing – toll roads and power plants going back decades.
You know, project finance and structured credit is not a new phenomenon. How and when does cash get disbursed? And who controls those decisions?
So, you can protect yourself [so] that if something's going wrong, you don't have cash hemorrhaging out of the system uncontrollably. Things like that, they really matter.
Vishy Tirupattur: You know, one other thing that I keep thinking about is whether the constraint is people or power availability, cost of capital or, you know, potential policy constraints. You know, some sort of a slowdown in AI CapEx is viewed rather cautiously by the equity markets.
How do you think credit markets will handle, you know, a slowdown for any number of reasons in the pace of CapEx spend?
Dan Toscano: Yeah. Well, I mean, I think the pace of CapEx spend gets measured against [a] company's ambitions. Not anything else. It's – We see an opportunity, we would like to take advantage of that opportunity. And in order to do so, we need to build capacity, right?
So, what happens? Client says, "I want this thing built yesterday, not in a week." Okay. So, if it slows down relative to someone's ambitions, it doesn't really create a problem in my mind. All it means is gratification delayed.
So, I think this can speed up, I think it can slow down, as fast as people are comfortable. And when I say people, I mean investors putting capital behind management teams. But I also think management teams feeling comfortable that they can control what they're doing and when they're building capacity… If they're buying chips or selling chips or trafficking in compute, they can speed up or slow down based on the environment around them without consequence.
I think people get worried. And here's one element of timing that does matter, is, you know, once you put a shovel in the ground. And by shovel, I mean dollars, right? Time is money. And there's a lot of work being done around managing the cash flows, leading up to the construction of a data center, throughout the construction itself, which can take 12 to 24 months. And that assumes an environment that is friendly and conducive toward building data centers.
And that's where it really matters.
Vishy Tirupattur: So last question for you, Dan. I know you're a big UConn basketball fan. Other than the UConn basketball team prospects, what keeps you up at night in the context of AI financing?
Dan Toscano: Yeah. Look, I mean, AI keeps a lot of people up at night. It doesn't keep me up at night. What keeps me up at night is UI.
Vishy Tirupattur: U of I, University of Illinois, Fighting Illini, ranked number three ahead of UConn, may I remind you.
Dan Toscano: December 4th, United Center, Chicago, Illinois, I will see you there.
Vishy Tirupattur: I'll see you in Chicago, Dan. Thanks for taking the time to talk to us.
Dan Toscano: My pleasure, Vish. Great to see you.
Vishy Tirupattur: And thanks for listening. If you enjoy the podcast, please leave us a review wherever you listen and share Thoughts on the Market with a friend or colleague today.
Seth Carpenter: Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Seth Carpenter, Morgan Stanley's Global Chief Economist and Head of Macro Research.
Michael Gapen: I'm Michael Gapen, Chief U.S. Economist.
Jens Eisenschmidt: I'm Jens Eisenschmidt, Chief Europe Economist.
Chetan Ahya: And I'm Chetan Ahya, Chief Asia Economist.
Seth Carpenter: And today, our fourth quarterly economic roundtable discussion is going to try to take a wide-angle view on the global economy – and it has held up despite higher interest rates, higher energy prices, geopolitical uncertainty, you name it.
It's Thursday, October 22nd at 10am in New York.
Jens Eisenschmidt: And 4pm in Frankfurt.
Chetan Ahya: And 10 pm in Hong Kong.
Seth Carpenter: All right then. Let me start with that big question Why has global growth held up better than maybe would have been expected given everything that we've seen ?
Mike, maybe I'll start from the U.S. perspective with you. What do you think has mattered most? What is driving – if I dare use an overused word – the resilience of the economy?
Michael Gapen: Most of us believe AI-related spending is interest rate insensitive and geopolitically insensitive. And certainly, I think the data has borne that out. And in the direct translation of AI hypercaler Capex spending to growth, we find that AI is accounting for 4/10 to 6/10 contribution to growth in any given quarter. You could nudge that a little higher if you think it’s creating productivity, which we do.
And that spending is underpinning asset market appreciation – or certainly has for the past several years. And that is underpinning resilient spending by upper income households.
So, I think in the U.S. the clear answer is AI-related spending, but also its linkage to asset markets and upper-income households.
Seth Carpenter: Jens, let me come to you for the European view. I mean the AI story has been a little bit different in Europe. I think consumer behavior sometimes can differ in Europe than in the United States.
What would you say is the story behind the resilience of economic growth there in Europe?
Jens Eisenschmidt: It’s similar in the sense that there is a clear element of also of AI-related external demand. That even in Europe now the phones are ringing, given that we are more typically seen as on the more higher cost end of the spectrum.
So, I think there was clearly in the second quarter data, export-led growth elements related to AI or delivery into that. There was also an element of geopolitical tensions helping some of those producers – say, chemical industry in Germany comes to mind – that would deliver products that would previously be delivered out of the Strait [of Hormuz].
So, that is another element. And then, yeah, the consumer held up [00:04:00] better than had expected. Or that you could have expected given the rise in energy prices. So all in all, that got us a relatively solid second quarter print. And we expect this to be more or less repeated also in the third.
Seth Carpenter: Chetan, the export story is pretty important. You've been writing about a big CapEx cycle and big industrial cycle in Asia. So, when you think about the Asia story and why the economic growth held up in spite of the global shocks, how would you characterize that?
Chetan Ahya: Yeah. So, Asia is benefiting from a strong pickup in CapEx, which initially was led by the tech sector, but is now broadening out to energy, defense, and broader industrial investments. Exports are strong, and showing some signs of broadening out from tech to non-tech goods too.
This has meant that the region has faced positive terms of trade situation despite higher oil prices. Higher export prices have boosted corporate profits and in turn government tax revenues, offsetting the fiscal pressures from higher fuel subsidies.
And when you're thinking about higher interest rates that you are seeing globally and also in Asia, what is different in this cycle is that the macro stability indicators are in a good place. Current account surpluses in the region have widened quite significantly. In fact, it is $1.6 trillion or 4.2 percent of GDP.
Also what we have is the private sector balance sheets outside of China are quite healthy.
So, all in all, both higher oil prices and interest rates have not disturbed the CapEx and growth cycle in the region.
Seth Carpenter: Is there a lot of dispersion across sectors, across countries for this cycle that you’re talking about? Can you go a little deeper there?
Chetan Ahya: Yeah. So let me start first with the story [00:09:00] on investment versus consumption So initially, the growth story in the region started with a pickup in exports and CapEx. But what we have seen is that this has now broadened out into a dynamic where we see an improvement in the labor market and therefore consumption growth.
So, we have this recovery broadening out from exports to CapEx to consumption.
And within the region, when you're thinking about different economies. Initially, we saw very strong growth in Korea and Taiwan. But now we have seen growth being strong in all parts of the region, especially in economies like India, Japan, and also some of the Southeast Asian economies like Malaysia and Singapore.
Seth Carpenter: I want to stay on this broadening theme, Michael.
Is all of the CapEx spending, all the investment spending, by business in the United States, is it just an AI story? Are we seeing any broadening of the investment story in the U.S. beyond AI? Or should we just resign ourselves that the rest of the economy is going to stagnant?
Michael Gapen: No, I do think we are seeing evidence of [00:11:00] some broadening out. It is most clear in manufacturing.
So, I do think it points to some broadening out in the AI story beyond the narrow AI story into something that is broader that both Chetan and Jens have referenced about in a multipolar world needing to build out redundancies in supply chain.
Maybe there's some incentive to do some reshoring. So, whether it's a spillover effect from AI or a spillover effect from geopolitics writ large, I do think there's some evidence that we're seeing the broadening out.
I would just caution and say, just remember, manufacturing in the U.S. is relatively small. It's only about 10 percent of output and maybe 10 percent of employment. But nonetheless, it's there. So, it's not just an AI story. I think you can characterize it as a bit broader.
Seth Carpenter: Let me come to you, Jens, on this. We've seen an investment story play out for a while in Europe. There was a lot of discussion about defense especially in Germany –infrastructure especially in Germany.
Is that still an important part of spending in Europe, the investment side of things? And how important is investment relative to household?
Jens Eisenschmidt: Yeah. No, I mean, I think in, in terms of the shares; and GDP shares in spending, you're talking about 50 percent versus 20 percent. So, consumption is the more important one…
If you talk about relative [00:13:00] expectations, so I think there your question really points at a key component of the forecast. If anything, you could expect maybe some more dampening from here, given that energy prices have increased further, and at some point the consumer will just capitulate. Or at least, need to show some signs of retracement. While investment has so far, in the aggregate at least, not shown any signs of a big revival.
And if anything, this is what we would expect more investment from here – be it related to, you know, a progressive AI build out.
Or be it because we anyway expect some more positive investment dynamics given where we are in the cycle and given that the ECB has decreased rates last year. And at some point, this typically shows up in investment demand.
So, long story short, the relative importance as a growth driver should increase of investments, vis-a-vis consumption. I think that is that is relatively clear. The question is just the magnitude here.
Seth Carpenter: How much do you worry then that not only is investment going to become bigger share of growth? That consumption could weaken even more because energy prices chip away at purchasing power of households? Is that a relevant factor for Europe?
Jens Eisenschmidt: I think that has to be the ma- number one growth worry going forward So essentially, you come down in terms of wage increases from very high level that were reflective of past inflation.
So, the European wage setting process always lags inflation, and so basically today's wage agreements are reflective of yesterday's inflation.
But now we are going above 4 percent, very likely on our forecast. Not an awful lot above 4 percent, but still above.
Then it becomes a question of [00:16:00] how long this is going to persist. If you just believe the future curves in energy markets – not long. But then if you look at more details in terms of, for instance, where diesel prices are likely heading, you can become more pessimistic, and ultimately, this is what matters for the consumer. So long story short, big risks here, of course.
Seth Carpenter: All right. So, a consumer that's not exactly pulling its weight leads me back to China. Key economy in the world, one of the biggest economies going. But when it comes to demand, aggregate demand, China has been in this deflationary cycle for a while. The household sector has been pretty soft in terms of its demand.
What are we looking at there in terms of the consumer in China, the demand side of things in China? is that likely to [00:17:00] change anytime soon? And can the global economy look to China as a source of extra demand to keep this expansion going?
Chetan Ahya: Unfortunately, I think the short answer to your question is no. We are still very cautious on China's consumption outlook. And what we have been characterizing the China growth story as it's going through a K-shaped recovery.
On one side, you have the strength in exports and AI CapEx. And on the other hand, we have a very weak consumer.
Now, why is the consumption growth weak in China? So firstly, the property sector has still not [00:18:00] completed the adjustment cycle.
So, from consumer standpoint, they have still a weak labor market and wage income growth. On top of that, they have seen this massive decline in asset prices. And, so they are actually, de-leveraging at a very rapid pace. The outstanding debt for consumers is contracting at the rate of 1.5 percent. 1.5 percent is not a big number, but just to see that contraction is quite surprising.
And so therefore, all in [00:19:00] all, China's consumption growth continues to remain weak. We do think that there is a possibility that the policymakers respond to this weak growth and provide some support. But we're not expecting that support to be big fiscal expansion in a way that you get a major surprise on the consumption outlook for China.
Seth Carpenter: But as we started off saying, things are holding up, and so that fact brings up a question in my mind. Where are the risks? Where are the downside risks? And so, Mike, maybe I'll start with you.
What do you think would lead to a downturn in the U.S.? Where's the biggest vulnerability? What do we have to look out for?
Michael Gapen: Well, I think in the, the near [00:20:00] term, I do think higher rates pose a vulnerability. So, I would say if the central bank has to shift to a much more dramatic tightening cycle and interest rates go a lot higher, that would be a near-term vulnerability. But I think if we look further out, if the resiliency of the economy is driven by the AI investment cycle, then I think a potential over-investment cycle is the greater risk.
Seth Carpenter: Alright. Jens, what about in, in Europe?
Jens Eisenschmidt: Clearly we have a discussion among European, in particular monetary policymakers, as evidenced [00:21:00] by the latest accounts of the ECB about the degree to which long rates have increased. Maybe, too much and, you know, present a significant tightening of financial conditions.
And juggling that in a good way will certainly be a risk and reason to be cautious.
So, I would say, here the three risks. Again, consumption because of energy prices, interest rates, or a too tight monetary policy stance. And of course, the investment cycle overall.
Seth Carpenter: Chetan, you get the last word in Asia
Chetan Ahya: So, I would say, Seth, two risks. One is higher oil prices and the second one is, if you see a contraction in AI investments in the U.S. and therefore in Asia as well.
So, on oil prices, I would say a threshold of $130 to $150 of oil would be a problem for the region. It would make the governments finally do resort to higher oil prices for the consumers.
And if you get a combination of higher oil prices and lower AI investments, that would be quite a big shock to the region's growth outlook.
Seth Carpenter: Super helpful. And I think that's probably a good place for us to stop for today.
We talked about global growth. It's been holding up really well. Sources of that resilience probably differ a bit across regions, but investment is important and becoming probably more important over time. And that investment boom is spreading through trade. Domestic demand in parts for Asia. Europe has got its own story going on. And obviously, the consumer around the world matters a lot.
That current outlook though, of a reasonably strong economy with this shock from energy that's driving up inflation, means that the policy side of things, especially monetary policy, is now becoming kind of complicated.
So, what should a central bank do? When we come back tomorrow, we're going to ask questions about the Fed, the ECB, the Bank of England, the Bank of Japan. How they're thinking about what's going on, the tightening that needs to be done, whether or not this is going to be a fully synchronized hiking cycle.
And I guess most of all, what's going to tell us when the policy hiking has gone far?
Mike, Jens, Chetan, thanks so much for joining today. And to the listener, thank you for listening, and be sure to tune in tomorrow for part two of our conversation.
And if you enjoy this show, please leave us a review wherever you listen and share Thoughts on the Market with a friend or a colleague today.
Sign up to get Morgan Stanley Ideas delivered to your inbox.
Thank you for Subscribing!
Thank you for your interest in Morgan Stanley Ideas.