When Should You Take Social Security?

When to claim isn’t always about maximizing your benefits. Explore how spending needs, health, spousal factors and policy shifts can influence the decision.

Author
Dan Hunt, Senior Investment Strategist

Key Takeaways

  • Delaying claims can increase monthly income for life, but it often requires higher portfolio withdrawals early in retirement, amplifying risks if you face volatile markets.
  • For retirees who are less well-funded, claiming earlier can actually reduce the risk of running out of money by easing pressure on savings during vulnerable years.
  • Policy uncertainty is a real variable, and some retirees may value locking in benefits earlier under current rules.
  • For couples, coordination matters because spousal and survivor benefits can influence lifetime household income.

For many people approaching retirement, Social Security feels like one of the few constants left — government-backed, inflation-adjusted and guaranteed for life. And yet, one of the most consequential decisions retirees make is when to claim it.

 

On the surface, the choices seem simple enough: Claim early and receive smaller checks for longer, or wait and receive larger checks for fewer years. That framing has fueled a cottage industry of calculators promising to identify the “optimal” claiming age.

 

But here’s the problem: Maximizing total benefits is complex, personal and not the only consideration. The Social Security claiming decision also can be viewed through the lens of maximizing retirement security, and the answers differ depending on the choice of objective.

 

Getting the most out of Social Security first requires an understanding of what you value the most. Here are a few considerations as you plan for this next phase of life. 

Hello, and welcome to a special edition of Wealth Management Insights. I’m Dan Hunt, head of Decision Analytics and Client Enablement. Today we’re going to discuss the complex challenge of determining when to claim your Social Security benefits. This is a critical decision for those planning for retirement, and we can help you navigate the tradeoffs.

When you claim Social Security benefits, it affects both the size of your benefit check and how many checks you will ultimately receive. The rules allow you to file for Social Security benefits as early as age 62, and the tradeoff involved at every point thereafter is that deferring the claiming of your benefits for a year means a larger monthly check when you do claim, up until age 70, after which benefits don’t increase with deferral.

This sets up a math problem: Starting earlier means more checks; waiting means larger checks when they start coming. Unfortunately, the math behind the problem is actually more complicated than it seems. That’s because simply adding the benefits one would receive over an average lifetime for each claiming age and choosing the biggest sum errs due to several complicating factors.

To list a few, money received today can be invested to be worth more than money received in the future, health status varies, longevity is uncertain regardless, and the problem for couples is yet more complex, due to the interdependencies in the rules for Social Security and varying ages. Perhaps the most important complicating factor is that there’s more to choosing when to claim than just maximizing benefits. There is also consideration for your broader finances and what that means for the risk of running out of money in retirement.

To delve into some of these factors a bit, health status is obviously an important consideration when claiming benefits. If you're in better-than-average health, an average lifespan may be a conservative estimate of how long you will receive benefits and what you may need to support your retirement. In such circumstances, delaying benefits is more attractive. Conversely, poor health will generally increase the attractiveness of claiming early.

However, if your primary objective is not running out of money in retirement, health may play a smaller role. That’s because even unlikely longevity events are important when constructing a retirement income plan, and Social Security’s inflation indexing provides a valuable hedge against an unexpectedly long retirement. This highlights why it's so important to be explicit about priorities when making a claiming decision.

Another important consideration is financial status. For retirees with ample assets to fund their income, waiting for larger benefits is unlikely to have a material impact on their income plan. However, those who are less well funded may experience a greater impairment of their nest egg during periods of volatility if they defer, due to the higher portfolio withdrawals from savings in the years between retirement and delayed claiming benefits. For these individuals, claiming early can help lower the risk of running out of money.

The uncertainty surrounding the status of the Social Security program is another factor that is worth considering. The Trust Fund that supports Social Security could be depleted by 2033, after which incoming payroll taxes would cover only about 77% of promised benefits. Among the many options politicians will have to explore to deal with this funding gap, benefit cuts for current retirees are among the least palatable, but remain a meaningful possibility, perhaps on a means-tested basis, given the magnitude of the fiscal gap that will need filling—something that would make earlier claiming more attractive in terms of expected benefits.

Legislative adjustments are ultimately highly uncertain, so while potential benefit cuts are an important factor, they remain a speculative input to the process for now.

If you're married, coordinating your claiming strategy with your spouse can help to maximize household income and hedge against difficult financial circumstances for a surviving spouse. Spousal benefits can pay up to 50% of the higher earner’s full retirement age benefit once the primary spouse has filed. Survivor benefits can reach 100% of the deceased spouse’s benefit if the survivor does not claim before their full retirement age.

The claiming age chosen by the primary earner does not change the formula for spousal benefits, but it does set the baseline for survivorship benefits. Our findings suggest that age gaps are an important element of the claiming strategy for couples. When a primary earner is the younger spouse, it very quickly becomes more beneficial to claim as early as 62, depending on other factors. When the primary earner is older, the magnitude of the gap in their ages matters, with small gaps favoring later claiming and very large gaps favoring earlier claiming.

If you take nothing else from the long list of considerations discussed so far, it should be that the mechanics of the Social Security claiming decision are too complex for back-of-the-envelope math. Capturing all of the relevant mechanics, plus others such as tax implications, requires specialized, sophisticated software.

Just as important as the math is working with an expert to help you quantify the salient factors and the specific contours of your own aspirations to make sure that you are framing the questions the right way. Everyone is different and what they hope to achieve is often different. Getting the most out of Social Security first requires an understanding of what you value the most.

Thank you for joining us today. For more insights about Social Security, how to maximize it and how to align it with your goals and objectives, please reach out to your Morgan Stanley Financial Advisor. We look forward to hearing from you.

Wealth Management

When to Claim Social Security?

Deciding when to claim Social Security isn’t a quick math calculation—it’s a high-stakes retirement move that can shape both your monthly income and how long your money lasts. Dan Hunt breaks down the real-world tradeoffs between claiming as early as 62 or delaying up to 70, and why the smartest answer depends on more than just the size of the check.

Delaying Social Security: Pros and Cons

Let’s start with basic math. Claiming Social Security benefits as early as age 62 can provide income sooner, but at a permanent reduction.1  Waiting until what the government terms “full retirement age” (between 66 and 67 based on your birth year), or even age 70, can raise monthly benefits meaningfully. Over a long enough life, delaying can result in higher cumulative payments.

 

But those breakeven calculations assume certainty about how long you’ll live, and no one has that. Just as importantly, they ignore what happens between retirement and claiming. If you delay Social Security, you’re often drawing more heavily from your portfolio in the early years, precisely when market volatility can do the most damage. This is what planners call sequence-of-returns risk: Poor market performance early in retirement can permanently impair a financial plan, even if long-term returns turn out fine.

 

For retirees who are less well-funded, claiming earlier can actually reduce the risk of running out of money. That’s because even though the checks are smaller, they arrive sooner and thus can reduce pressure on savings during vulnerable years.

Maximizing Your Benefits: Longevity Matters

The “right” claiming age depends on what you’re trying to optimize.

 

If your sole goal is maximizing expected lifetime benefits, health assumptions matter a great deal. Longer life expectancy generally favors delaying benefits, and shorter life expectancy favors claiming earlier.

 

But if your goal is minimizing the risk of income shortfall — of being forced to cut spending later in life — the calculus changes. Funding status matters more than health, and well-funded retirees can typically afford to wait, while less-funded retirees often can’t.

Factoring in Policy Risks

The Social Security Trust Fund is projected to face depletion in the next decade.2 If lawmakers fail to act, benefits could be reduced across the board. While benefit cuts remain politically unpopular, the possibility of future cuts can influence behavior: Some people may claim earlier to lock in benefits under today’s rules and reduce the risk of being affected by a future reduction.

Couples May Face Additional Considerations

For couples, the decision becomes even more complex. Social Security isn’t just about one lifespan — it’s often about two. Spousal and survivor benefits introduce additional tradeoffs, particularly when there’s an age gap between partners. Spousal benefits can pay up to 50% of the higher earner’s full retirement age benefit once the primary spouse has filed.3 Survivor benefits can reach 100% of the deceased spouse’s benefit if the survivor does not claim before full retirement age.4

 

In many cases, the primary earner’s claiming decision shapes household income for decades, especially if one spouse lives much longer than expected. The result is that couples often face very different “optimal” claiming ages than single retirees. As such, coordinated planning matters far more than individual maximization.

Working with Your Morgan Stanley Financial Advisor

The larger takeaway is this: Social Security is not a plug-and-play decision. It’s a critical resource that can have powerful risk-management effects for your retirement income plan: one of the few sources of guaranteed, inflation-adjusted income available in retirement. The question isn’t just how much you’ll collect, but how it interacts with your portfolio, your spending, your health, your spouse and an uncertain policy future.

 

There is no universal right answer on when to start claiming your benefits. But there is a right process, one that moves beyond oversimplified calculators and focuses on tradeoffs, not just totals. And for most retirees, that shift in perspective can make all the difference.

 

To learn more, ask your Morgan Stanley Financial Advisor for a copy of the Global Investment Office report, “When to Claim Social Security? Here’s How to Navigate the Tradeoffs,” by Dan Hunt.   

Discover more

 Insights to help you go further.